Witness sticks to her allegations against Combs
In the most direct and pointed cross-examination yet, Combs’ defense lawyer Steel asked “Mia” if she was wrong — and that his client never had nonconsensual sex with her.
“What I said is true,” the unwavering witness said. “I have not lied to anyone at all.”
Steel asked Mia if she overestimated the number of times Combs might have inappropriately touched her.
“Everything I said in this courtroom is true,” she said.
Witness said blaming herself was a defense mechanism
“Mia” testified blaming herself for being the victim of sexual assault was her coping mechanism and shouldn’t interpreted as an excuse for the alleged perpetrator.
“I am a sexual assault victim, just survive,” she said during cross-examination. “I’m unraveling a lot of this now in therapy. Nobody told me, nobody was there to say the things that were happening were wrong.”
In Combs’ world, the victims were always made to feel at fault, she said.
“I was always in trouble and always finding a way not to be in trouble,” Mia explained.
Trump, asked about pardoning Combs, says he would ‘look at the facts’
Trump is not ruling out a pardon for Combs, telling reporters in the Oval Office this afternoon that he would “certainly look at the facts.”
Trump, asked by Fox News’ Peter Doocy whether he would consider taking that step, said “nobody’s asked” but added that “people are thinking about it.”
Trump went on to say that he hasn’t seen or spoken to Combs in years, and that he hasn’t followed Combs’ trial closely.
In a 2012 episode of “The Apprentice,” Trump called Combs “a good friend of mine” and “a good guy.”
In his second term, Trump has issued pardons for various celebrities, including reality stars Todd and Julie Chrisley; rapper NBA YoungBoy; and hip-hop star Lil Wayne.
‘Mia’ acknowledges she posted Combs on Instagram often, but says all his staffers were expected to post
“Mia” is very engaged during the cross-examination and is confidently claiming ownership of her Instagram posts featuring and praising Combs, despite defense attorney Brian Steel’s attempt to show the disconnect between her claims of suffering at Combs’ hands and her glowing posts about him.
Mia doubled down saying that everyone who worked for Combs was expected to post. She reiterated that back then, people tended to post only about the high moments in life, not the lows.
Combs is the ‘coolest alien rockstar’ around, alleged victim says
The defense is continuing its effort to minimize any bad acts by Combs, by citing previous kind words from “Mia.”
She effusively praised Combs in a social media posting with pictures of his birthday celebration in late 2016.
The caption Mia wrote and shown in court included a praising F-bomb: “You are the coolest alien rockstar unicorn pizza slice and we f—— lovvvve you!”
Party on annivers of alleged sexual assault
The defense showed pictures of “Mia” at a party wishing Combs a happy birthday — on what would have been the six-year annivers of a sexual assault she testified he committed against her.
Mia said she just learned to “shut it down” for that moment.
“I tried to protect that night and shut it down and not think about it again,” she said.
The defense made Mia read what she wrote about Combs on this birthday: “Legend, rapper, actor, entrepreneur, an extraterrestrial was born, happy bday thank you for showing me the path to Pluto and beyond.”
Court back in session
Court is back in session following a lunch break.
Court breaks for the lunch hour
Judge Subramanian dismissed the jurors for lunch, asking them to return to court before 1:15 p.m. EDT.
The defense will continue its cross-examination of “Mia,” in hopes of minimizing the prosecution witness’s damaging testimony by emphasizing how she might’ve benefited from her Combs employment.
When defense attorney Brian Steel asked if Combs was good for her career, Mia conceded it was fun at times.
Defense wants to show the good times in Combs world
There were clearly some good times during the stint “Mia” had working for Combs and his side of the table wants jurors to see it.
Defense lawyers showed a video of Mia laughing in a comedy video with Rick Ross and images of her celebrating a birthday of Combs’ son Justin.
In her direct testimony, Mia didn’t deny there were some good times in Combs world — but made it clear that the highs were more than offset by the lows.
Defense tries to corner ‘Mia’ on contradictions
The defense questioned “Mia” on her social media posts with Combs and on her communications with him in which she said “love you” and praised him as a “mentor and inspiration.”
She defended the posts as showing the good parts of her life. When asked why she promoted the person who stole her happiness, she said, “I had to support the things Puff supported. It was very confusing, ups and downs.”
The defense tried to call out contradictions in Mia’s testimony — where she said she was in constant fear of upsetting Combs, but would post about being his best friend.
“It’s easy because the dynamic would shift. When things are good, I felt really safe, you almost forget about those things,” she said, referring to the bad memories. She later said: “It was psychological. I felt responsible for helping him. I felt bad for him. I don’t know how to describe it.”
Defense seeking to minimize testimony by ‘Mia’ about abuse
Combs’ defense is clearly trying to undermine “Mia’s” gripping testimony by showing her — and jurors — pictures and social media posts between the two in less-fraught times.
Defense attorney Brian Steele had Mia go through a binder of material showing her and the defendant appearing to enjoy each other’s company.
One picture, which appeared to be from a Burning Man festival in 2013, included Mia, Ventura and Combs.
“You’re standing right next to and leaning toward him, the man who terrorized you?” Steele asked, drawing a “yes” from Mia.
Mia was also shown a YouTube comedy bit, directed by Andy Samberg, depicting her in a hospital gown giving birth with Combs acting as obstetrician.
Cross-examination is about to begin
The defense will now begin to question “Mia.”
‘Mia’ says she hasn’t been able to work due to PTSD
When asked under direct examination if she works now, “Mia” said she hasn’t been able to because “I suffer from severe complex PTSD” following her employment with Combs.
She explained that normal situations are “overwhelming” and she feels triggered when someone asks “Where are you?” or if someone says her name across the room.
Witness testifies Combs reached out to her after Ventura lawsuit
After Ventura filed her lawsuit against Combs, “Mia” testified the defendant reached out to her, but she said she steered clear of him.
The government showed a Feb. 7, 2024, email from Combs to Mia in which he used kind words in asking for a phone call to have “my memory jogged on a few things.”
But Mia said she didn’t respond.
“I was terrified,” she said. “I know this was a front.”
Mia said she’s believed Combs was fearful of her telling anyone what she’d seen the defendant do over the years.
“Puff wanted (Combs security guard) D-Roc to get to me and make sure I wasn’t a threat,” Mia told jurors.
‘Mia’ testifies she stopped working for Combs in 2017 after he decided to shut down Revolt Films
In the fall of 2016, Combs no longer wanted to be involved in Revolt Films and wanted to end it, “Mia” testified. Revolt Films is a media company founded by Combs that Mia worked for as director of development and acquisition.
She said she felt betrayed, confused and rejected by the decision. She continued to work on a document project until spring of 2017. She testified she was “heartbroken” by the decision to close Revolt Films, meaning she’d lose her position, and avoided calls from Combs and staff.
She eventually hired an employment attorney to work out severance, which hurt Combs. After nine months of back-and-forth, she ended up with a sum of $400,000, and took home $200,000 with attorneys taking the rest as compensation for bonuses owed, severance and overtime, she said.
‘Mia’ testifies Combs could explode in rage over anything
“Mia” testified about her recollection of a 2011 incident when she says Combs reacted violently after he asked her to bring him some workout clothes — and the defendant allegedly lost it when he disliked all options presented to him.
“He was just screaming and cursing at me and wouldn’t stop, and then something violent happened,” Mia said, though she couldn’t remember the exact details of this alleged violent act.
When James Cruz, a Bad Boy manager, emailed Mia that day asking who in the company was handling Kids’ Choice Awards ticket requests, the witness responded: “I’d totally help but I’m he is currently firing me at the moment.”
‘Call me now’
The jury got a look at Combs’ alleged insatiable need for employees to respond immediately.
The government showed an odd text conversation between “Mia” and Combs with the defendant spouting off with seven consecutive lines of: “Call me now.”
Witness testifies Combs left threatening texts and voicemails after he was caught cheating
Cassie Ventura had caught Combs cheating on her and was left “devastated” and stopped answering his calls when she was in South Africa shooting a movie and Combs was in Miami, “Mia” told the court.
Mia said she woke up to 48 missed calls and messages from Combs and others who worked for him.
‘Mia’ testifies Combs made threats — to kill her and report her to HR
In an Oct. 26, 2015, WhatsApp chat between “Mia” and Combs’ then-chief of staff Kristina Khorram, the witness said Combs “doesn’t sound in his right mind.”
Combs was threatening to kill her and take her to HR, Mia testified.
The peculiar threat of both violence and taking formal employment measures could be one more piece of evidence for prosecutors seeking to show how Combs allegedly used his work as part of a criminal enterprise.
Failure to follow every one of Combs’ orders had a range of consequences, Mia said.
“I would have been in big trouble, gotten fired, lost my job, emotionally or possibly physically abused,” the witness said.
‘Mia’ returns to the stand
Mia has returned to the stand, wearing a cream blouse and white jacket, for a second day of direct examination.
Defense wants more time with Combs; judge says there are limits
The defense continued its call for more time to meet with Combs outside courtroom hours and U.S. District Court Judge Arun Subramanian appeared to say there might not be much more he can do to help.
The judge said he could have Combs available to his lawyers, in person, for up to 90 minutes in the morning following at 7 a.m. courthouse arrival and then for another 2½ hours after jurors are sent home.
Those hours are already maxing out the U.S. Marshals Service, the judge added.
Defense attorney Marc Agnifilo said his side can’t properly show Combs documents and exhibits in his holding space.
Subramanian said he appreciates Combs’ unique needs and will try to get more time and space for the defense. But at some point, the defense might have to accept it’s getting more time with Combs than almost any other federal defendant, the judge added.
Court is in session
Court is now in session for day 13 of Combs’ racketeering and sex trafficking trial.
Lawyers arrive at court
Combs’ attorneys were seen arriving at court after 8 a.m. Marc Agnifilo dodged a reporter’s question about whether he watched the Knicks game last night.
Witness became emotional recalling alleged sexual assault by Combs
Mia testified all day yesterday. At first, she answered questions calmly but later became emotional and struggled to catch her breath as she described Combs’ relationship with Cassie Ventura.
She cried when recounting Combs allegedly forcing himself on her sexually, and wept as she recalled feeling “terrified and trapped.”
Here’s a recap of yesterday
Yesterday, a former personal assistant to Sean Combs, identified by the pseudonym “Mia,” testified about working for him from 2009 to 2017.
She testified that Combs sexually assaulted her multiple times, and he had her work grueling hours, including once going as many as five days without sleep. She also said she saw Combs be violent toward his ex-girlfriend, Cassie Ventura.
“I’ve seen him crack her head open,” Mia said, noting she never saw Ventura fight back. During one vacation in the Turks and Caicos, Mia and Ventura barricaded themselves in a room as Combs banged on the door. “Puff is going to kill me,” Ventura purportedly said.
Parties still hopeful for testimony to end in early July
U.S. District Court Judge Arun Subramanian rarely passes up a chance to remind lawyers of his goal of wrapping up the case around the 4th of July.
And by all accounts, in the early days of this trial, both sides are reasonably hopeful they can have jurors deliberating by around July 4.
But defense lawyer Marc Agnifilo wanted to remind Subramanian on Thursday that even if the prosecution rests ahead of schedule, the defense’s case could still stretch toward the Fourth of July.
“It is fair for you to raise, so I am not raising expectations,” Subramanian said.
Mia set to face cross-examination
Victim-4, who is being identified in court only as “Mia,’ is set to return to the stand today after an exhausting day of testimony recounting numerous alleged incidents of violence and sexual assault.
Mia said she feared Combs’ power and wanted to take these traumatic experiences to the grave.
“I was going to die with this,” she said yesterday. “I didn’t want anyone to know ever.”